An engineer checking a protection relay against a network study on a rugged laptop
Power systems9 November 2026·10 min read

Arc flash and ETAP studies in Zimbabwe: what they are and when you need one

The most dangerous thing in a switch room is what nobody has calculated. A power system study turns guesses about fault levels and settings into real numbers.

In this article
  1. The four studies
  2. Why arc flash matters
  3. What lenders and utilities expect
  4. What the study needs from you
  5. What you receive
  6. How the arc flash calculation works
  7. Incident energy: how hard an arc hits a worker
  8. Reading the results
  9. The cheap fixes that come out of a study
  10. Where a study fits in Zimbabwean practice
  11. Where studies go wrong
  12. How AVEX GRID helps

Key points

  • Four studies make the usual set: load flow, short circuit, protection coordination and arc flash.
  • An arc flash study estimates the heat a worker could face, so labels and protective clothing match the real danger. IEEE 1584 is the common method.
  • ZETDC and lenders usually ask for these studies before approving a new connection or a solar plant.
  • Collect real data on site, such as nameplates and cable lengths. Do not guess.
  • The results often show cheap fixes. A setting change can cut the arc flash energy without buying new equipment.
中文摘要 · CHINESE SUMMARY

津巴布韦电弧闪络与ETAP研究:是什么、何时需要

  • 通常的研究包括四项:潮流计算、短路计算、保护整定配合和电弧闪络分析。
  • 电弧闪络分析估算工人可能承受的入射能量,使标签和防护服与实际危害相匹配(常用方法为IEEE 1584)。
  • 电网运营商和贷款方在批准新并网或光伏电站前,通常会要求提供这些研究。
  • 研究的质量取决于数据。现场收集铭牌和电缆长度是工作的一部分。
  • 结果往往显示低成本的改善方法:调整保护设定即可在不增加硬件的情况下降低入射能量。
  • AVEX GRID 使用ETAP建模,可远程研究并在当地进行现场勘查(英文沟通)。

联系方式:WhatsApp +7 900 131 7406,邮箱 inquiries@avexgrid.com。

A power-system study is a computer model of your electrical network. It answers questions that you cannot answer by looking at the switchgear, which is the set of switches, fuses and circuit breakers that control and protect your supply. How much current flows in a fault? Does the right breaker open first? How dangerous would an arc flash be at each panel? An arc flash is a violent burst of heat and light when electric current jumps through the air, for example inside a switchboard. This guide explains the four studies in plain terms and says when you need each one. It is written for owners and managers of mines, factories, farms, hospitals and solar plants.

The four studies

StudyQuestion it answersWhen you need it
Load flowAre voltages and cable loadings acceptable under normal and peak operation?New plant, extensions, new connection, voltage complaints
Short circuitHow large can fault current get, and are breakers and busbars rated for it?Adding generation, transformers or large motors; replacing switchgear
Protection coordinationWhen a fault occurs, does the nearest device clear it, without tripping the whole site?New protection, nuisance trips, grid-connection approval
Arc flashHow much heat energy could a worker face at each location during an arc fault?Workplace safety programme, labelling, PPE selection

Why arc flash matters

An arc flash is an explosive release of energy when current jumps between conductors. It can cause severe burns and damage equipment. How bad it is depends on two things: the fault current, and how fast the protection clears the fault. A slow breaker on a strong source can give a dangerous exposure, even at modest voltages.

The study estimates the incident energy and the arc-flash boundary at each panel. It uses methods such as IEEE 1584. So the labels and protective clothing match the real hazard, and not a generic rule.

An often-missed benefitMany arc flash results can be improved cheaply. You can add a maintenance mode, adjust a trip setting, or fit an arc-detecting relay. A relay is a protective device that senses a fault and tells a circuit breaker to trip. Any of these can cut the incident energy a great deal, without replacing switchgear.
Arc-flash incident energy against clearing timeRelative to a one-second clear time, same arc current
5%
0.05 s
10%
0.1 s
20%
0.2 s
30%
0.3 s
50%
0.5 s
100%
1 s

For a given arc current the energy released scales with arc duration, which is why faster protection settings lower the hazard. Source: IEEE 1584-2018 method; AVEX GRID calculation

What lenders and utilities expect

A solar plant, captive generator or large motor may connect to the network. When it does, the utility and the lender's engineer will want to see short-circuit and protection studies. They check two things. The new equipment must not go over the network's fault ratings. And its protection must work together with the utility's. Studies done early stop redesign after equipment is ordered. See also our guide to developing a solar IPP.

What the study needs from you

  1. Single-line diagrams, current and as-built.
  2. Transformer, generator, motor and cable data (nameplates, lengths, sizes).
  3. Protection device types, models and existing settings.
  4. Utility fault level at the point of supply, or the data to estimate it.
  5. A site walk to check that the drawing matches the plant.

What you receive

  • A modelled network in ETAP, with a data-quality note listing the assumptions.
  • Reports for load flow, short circuit (what happens when a fault sends a huge current through the network), coordination curves and arc flash.
  • Equipment that is over-duty, flagged with the fix.
  • Recommended settings and arc flash label data.
  • A short management summary with the actions in order of priority.

How the arc flash calculation works

The study starts from the short-circuit model. Incident energy depends on three things: the arcing current at each panel, how long the protection takes to clear it, and how far the worker stands from the arc.

Most studies use IEEE 1584-2018. It applies to three-phase systems from 208 V up to 15 kV. It replaces the single formula of the older edition with a set of equations for several electrode layouts. This is because an arc behaves differently in different set-ups. An arc inside a box with the conductors arranged vertically is not the same as one with the conductors horizontal, or one in open air. So for each piece of equipment the engineer must record the enclosure size, the gap between conductors, the electrode layout and a realistic working distance. For low-voltage switchgear, the working distance is commonly taken as about 455 millimetres.

The arcing current is lower than the bolted fault current. So a fault at a given panel can release more energy than the study first suggests. A lower current may be too small to trip an instantaneous element. The breaker's slower time-delay region then runs on. A careful study therefore calculates the incident energy at both a high and a low arcing current, and reports the worse of the two.

The short-circuit input must also be up to date. An outdated fault level gives wrong labels with a false sense of precision. For example, it may have been measured before a transformer or a solar plant was added. A transformer is a device that raises or lowers the voltage of electricity so it can travel on the grid and be used safely on site.

Incident energy: how hard an arc hits a worker

An arc turns electrical energy into heat in a very small space. What a person feels is the incident energy: the heat that lands on each square centimetre of skin at the distance they stand. It is measured in calories per square centimetre. About 1.2 cal/cm2 is enough for a second-degree burn. The full calculation in IEEE Std 1584-2018 is based on tests, but three rules drive every practical decision:

If you...The incident energy...What it means on site
Halve the time the protection takes to clear the faultHalvesA faster setting is usually the cheapest fix
Double the distance from the arcFalls to about a quarter in open airRemote racking and operation help most
Work inside switchgear (a closed box)Is higher than the open-air rule suggestsThe box focuses the heat, so panels are riskier than they look
Raise the available fault currentRisesA stronger supply is not always safer

Reading the results

Each location in the report carries an incident energy in calories per square centimetre, an arc flash boundary, and the working distance for which the figures apply. About 1.2 cal/cm² is the level usually taken as the start of a second-degree burn. The boundary is simply the distance at which the energy falls to that level. Anyone inside the boundary needs protective clothing rated for the calculated energy.

NFPA 70E is the workplace safety standard most employers follow. It gives two ways to choose the clothing. One is the incident energy analysis method, which uses the study. The other is the PPE category tables, which use the type of equipment and a set of conditions. You may not use both methods on the same equipment. The category tables also have limits on fault current and clearing time, and many industrial installations go beyond them. This is why many sites commission a study instead of relying on the tables.

The labels on the equipment should show the nominal voltage, the incident energy or the PPE category, the arc flash boundary and the date of the study. Labels are only as good as the study behind them, so the date matters. NFPA 70E expects the analysis to be reviewed at least every five years. It should be reviewed sooner after a major change to the network, such as a new transformer, a changed protection setting or a new source of generation.

The cheap fixes that come out of a study

The energy released is roughly in proportion to the clearing time. So the strongest lever is usually the protection setting. The chart above shows the link: halve the clearing time and you halve the energy. The usual measures, from cheapest to most expensive, are:

  • Maintenance mode switches. This is a temporary lower instantaneous setting. An electrician switches it on before working inside the panel, and off afterwards. It cuts the clearing time for the length of the task at little cost.
  • Lower instantaneous pickups on main breakers. This is done where the coordination study shows it will not cause nuisance trips on upstream devices.
  • Zone-selective interlocking, where breakers talk to each other. The device nearest the fault clears without delay, while the upstream devices stay coordinated.
  • Arc-detecting relays, which sense the light of an arc and trip in a few milliseconds. They are the most effective hardware measure on large switchboards.
  • Remote racking and remote switching, which take the worker out of the boundary altogether.

There is a trade-off. The lowest possible settings reduce coordination. A fault on a small feeder may then trip a main breaker and take down the whole site. A good study shows both effects together. This is why arc flash and protection coordination are best done in the same model by the same engineer. Protection coordination means setting breakers and relays so the one nearest a fault trips first and the rest of the plant keeps running.

Where a study fits in Zimbabwean practice

We have not found a Zimbabwean regulation that prescribes a particular arc flash method. In practice the references are IEEE 1584 for the calculation, and NFPA 70E or an equivalent internal standard for the work practice. The request usually comes from an insurer, a mine safety department, a lender's engineer or a utility reviewing a new connection.

The network of ZETDC, is also changing. There is more embedded generation, and more large motors on weak feeders. So fault levels and clearing times that were true five years ago may no longer hold.

Where studies go wrong

The software does the arithmetic correctly. The errors come from the inputs. The most common are:

  • A single-line diagram that no longer matches the plant.
  • A transformer impedance copied from a typical value instead of the nameplate.
  • Cable lengths taken from the drawing instead of measured on site.
  • Protection settings copied from the relay's documentation, instead of read from the relay itself.

Another source of error is the treatment of motors. Motors feed current into a fault for the first few cycles, and this raises the available current at nearby busbars. A fixed-speed motor of any size adds to the fault level. A large bank of drives behaves differently again.

Finally, the source matters. A site with a generator and the grid has at least two fault levels. The arc flash result must be reported for the worse operating case, with the other case noted.

A good study states its assumptions in plain language. It names the cases it ran and lists the items that were not checked on site. If a study does not tell you where it was uncertain, treat the labels with caution.

How AVEX GRID helps

Our lead engineer holds an MSc in Electrical Power Engineering and is a Professional Member of the Zimbabwe Institution of Engineers. We do the modelling remotely and collect site data on the ground in Zimbabwe, so overseas teams get the same deliverables as local ones.

What AVEX GRID can take off your hands

AVEX GRID is an engineer-led energy consultancy in Zimbabwe. We do the technical work that turns an energy investment into a plant that is licensed, connected, financed and performing, whether you are a local operator or an investor overseas.

Feasibility and bankable studiesYield, load and hybrid models, and the technical file lenders and ZERA read.
Power-system engineering (ETAP)Load flow, short circuit, arc flash and protection studies for approvals and safe design.
Licence and PPA technical supportZERA licence documents, ZETDC connection studies, PPA technical schedules.
Owner's engineerDesign review, testing and commissioning on your side of the EPC table.
Tariff, audit and compliance workMaximum-demand and power-factor savings, readiness for energy-management rules.
Remote plus on the groundModelling for overseas teams, with an engineer in Zimbabwe for site, utility and regulator work.

We quote fixed prices after a free scoping call and reply the same working day.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between the PPE category tables and an arc flash study?

The tables in NFPA 70E select protective clothing from equipment type and limits on fault current and clearing time. A study calculates the actual incident energy at each location. The two methods should not be mixed on the same piece of equipment, and many industrial sites fall outside the table limits.

How often should an arc flash study be updated?

NFPA 70E expects a review at intervals not exceeding five years, and sooner after a major change to the network, such as new generation, a transformer change or revised protection settings.

Do I need an arc flash study?

If workers open or work near live switchgear, a study is the recognised way to match labels and PPE to the hazard. It is also a common request from insurers and mine safety teams.

What software do you use?

ETAP for the models and calculations, with methods from IEC 60909 for short circuit and IEEE 1584 for arc flash.

How long does a study take?

It depends on network size and the quality of data. A small site can take days; a large mine or plant takes several weeks. We confirm the timeline after a scoping call.

Can you study a site remotely?

The modelling is remote. We arrange a site walk in Zimbabwe to collect and verify the data.

Topics: arc flash study ZimbabweETAP study Zimbabweprotection coordination studyshort circuit studyload flow study Zimbabweelectrical safety minespower system study

Sources and notes

General information to help you plan. The rules that apply to your site are confirmed by AVEX GRID against the current gazetted text, ZERA and ZETDC as part of the work. The sources used are listed below.

DJ

Devine Tafara Javangwe is the founder and lead consulting engineer at AVEX GRID. He holds an MSc in Electrical Power Engineering (Southern Federal University, 2025), is a Professional Member of the Zimbabwe Institution of Engineers and an IEEE member.

About the practice · Contact

Find out what is really in your switch room.

Send us your single-line diagram, even a rough one. We tell you which studies you need and what each costs, before you commit.

+263 78 488 9775 · Autherstone Street 21, Marondera, Zimbabwe · Remote across Southern Africa